Club Records
These records are a work in progress.
| Record attendance: | v Sheffield Wednesday (2050) |
| Highest league attendance: | (1009) v Chester FC |
| Highest FA Cup attendance: | (361) v Stalybridge Celtic (12/9/19) |
| Highest FA Trophy attendance: | (634) v Scarborough |
| Highest FA Vase attendance: | |
| Highest Senior Cup attendance: | (800) v Worksop Town (Final) (27/4/93) |
| Highest NPL Cup attendance: | (305) v Radcliffe Borough (Div 1 Cup) (25/3/97) |
| Highest NCEL Cup attendance: | |
| Lowest ever attendance: | (48) v Blyth Spartans (NPL League Cup) (8/1/13) |
| Highest average attendance in a season: | |
| Lowest average attendance in a season: | |
| Best ever league finish: | 11th Northern Premier League 09/10 |
| Best FA Cup run: | 4th Qualifying Round (03/04) |
| Best FA Trophy run: | 3rd Round (99/00) |
| Record win: | (17-1) v Oldham Town (31/8/07) |
| Highest League win: | (9-1) v Bridlington Town & Peterbrough United |
| Highest FA Cup win: | (17-1) v OldhamTown (31/8/07) |
| Highest FA Trophy win: | (5-0) v Clitheroe (8/10/16) |
| Highest FA Vase win: | (5-0) v Glossop NE |
| Highest S & H Senior cup win: | (8-0) v Caribbean Sports (17/12/94) |
| Highest NPL cup win: | (4-0) v Marine & Whitby Town (League Cup) |
| Highest NCEL cup win: | (7-1) v Rossington M (League Cup) (15/11/94) |
| Record loss: | (0-7) v Buxton |
| Biggest league defeat: | (0-7) v Buxton |
| Highest FA Cup defeat: | (0-6) v Shilden |
| Highest FA Trophy defeat: | (0-5) v Scarborough |
| Highest FA Vase defeat: | (0-5) v Brigg Town |
| Highest Senior cup defeat: | (0-6) v Ash House (12/11/89) |
| Highest NPL cup defeat: | (0-6) v Farsley Celtic (League Cup) (1/12/15) |
| Highest NCEL cup defeat: | (0-5) v Belper Town (Presidents Cup) (2/1/91) |
| Highest scoring game: | (17-1) v Oldham Town (31/8/07) |
| Highest scoring league game: | (9-1) v Bridlington Town & Peterbrough United |
| Highest scoring cup game: | (17-1) v Oldham Town (31/8/07) |
| Most goals scored in a match: | (17) v Oldham Town (31/8/07) |
| Most goals conceded in a match: | (7) v Witton Albion & Buxton |
| Most games won in a row: | |
| Most league games won in a row: | |
| Most games undefeated: | |
| Most league games undefeated: | |
| Most games lost in a row: | |
| Most league games lost in a row: | |
| Most games without a win: | |
| Most league games without a win: | |
| Most games without firing a blank: | |
| Most league games without firing a blank: | |
| Most games without scoring: | |
| Most league games without scoring: | |
| Most cleansheets in a row: | |
| Most league cleansheets in a row: | |
| Most games without a cleansheet: | |
| Most league games without a cleansheet: | |
| Most cleansheets in a season: | |
| Most league wins in a season: | |
| Most league draws in a season: | |
| Most league defeats in a season: | |
| Most league goals scored in a season: | |
| Most league goals conceded in a season: | |
| Best goal difference in a season: | |
| Most points in a season: | |
| Best points per game average: | |
| Highest league played in: | Northern Premier Division |
| Lowest league played in: | NCEL Division 2 |
| Highest step played at in non league pyramid: | Step 3 |
| Lowest step played at in non league pyramid: | Step 6 |
| Best record against (10 or more games): | |
| Worse record against (10 or more games): | |
| Team we’ve beaten the most (10 or more games): | |
| Team we’ve lost to the most (10 or more games): | |
| Most goals in a match: | 10 Paul Jackson |
| Most league goals in a match: | 4 Lee Mills, Gary Hurlestone, Joe Lumsden, Scott Ruthven |
| Record goalscorer : | |
| Record appearances: | |
| Most goals in a season: | |
| Most appearances in a season: | |
| Record league goalscorer: | |
| Record FA Cup goalscorer: | |
| Record FA Trophy goalscorer : | |
| Record Senior Cup goalscorer: | |
| Highest transfer fee Paid: | Undisclosed for Dave Cockerill |
| Highest transfer fee received: | £15,000 for Lee Mills |
| Players progressing to league clubs: | Lee Mills (Wolves), Simon Marples (Doncaster Rovers), Jamie Vardy (Leicester City), Ross Hannah (Bradford City), Jack Muldoon (Harrogate Town), Scott Horgan (Aston Villa) & Harrison Biggins (Fleetwood Town) |